Unlocking the Power of Millets in Regenerative Agriculture with Joanna Kane-Pataka
Download MP3Joanne, hello, everyone. You are
listening to the regenerative by
design podcast where we will be
getting to the root of health,
climate, economics and food. I
am your host. Joni quinwell
Moore, join me on this journey
as we explore the stories of
individuals and organizations
who are working to realign our
food system with both human
health and the health of our
planet. Greetings everybody, and
thank you so much for joining me
on the regenerative by design
Podcast. Today. We have Joanna
Kane Potaka joining us, of
course, to talk about millets.
Because everybody knows that I
am super passionate about
millets. And if you've ever
followed my work out in the wide
open world, you know that I do
spend a lot of energy
enthusiastically cheerleading
for such an incredible
underutilized crops such as
millet plural. So welcome,
Joanna. I'm so excited to talk
to you today.
Thanks, Joni. And you know, I
really want to say it's
absolutely fantastic how you're
taking a personal initiative to
really spread the word on
regenerative agriculture and
crops like like millet, which
are paradoxically actually you
you mentioned underutilized, but
it was the ancient grain. Now
it's forgotten and future food,
right?
It's funny how all things, all
do become new again. And it's
you know that again, it's part
of that regenerative
transformation that is coming
our way in food systems, where
we start to look to the past for
things that worked for millennia
and that we've conveniently just
eliminated from our modern food
systems, to the detriment of our
health and to the detriment of
our soils and and planets as
well. So Joanna, to get started,
because you have such a
fascinating background, and over
the years, it's just been so
much fun learning about your
work, learning about your past
work. Could you tell our
audience a little bit about
where you came from and what
you've done and how you came to
be where you are today?
I to do that very quickly. Well,
actually, I started in research
as a scientist, an economist and
market research, but I always
had this driving, first to work
overseas, and I got two
opportunities at the same time.
One was working commercial
marketing and sort of food
industry in Australia, and the
other was to work overseas for
nonprofits. And I must admit, I
chose to work overseas for
nonprofits mainly because I
wanted to work overseas. But in
the meantime, I absolutely fell
in love with the work of
nonprofits and this whole
Agriculture and Food space,
which is just so critical and
has become even bigger over
time, with the with climate
change and much more awareness
around like you say, the
regenerative agriculture, the
need for diversity, the
challenges that we have with
water and soil. So, yeah, I just
fell in love with that, and then
I guess I've been really
privileged to work in so many
countries on so many of these
topics, and then I had in as
part of that student I had nine
years in India, and that's where
I'd never heard of millets
before, and that's where I first
heard about them and and really,
just started my very first
research on them, and and came
to realize, Wow, this is a gold
field that is wasn't brought up
on global attention. There were
a number of people in
organizations pushing it, but it
was really, really under, under,
mis, under understood, yeah, the
value of it. And so then I
became converted, and big
advocate for, yeah, yeah,
it's fantastic. Now, you know,
you've, you've really balanced
that line between the economics,
the education, the nutrition
components. And you know, with
some of your more recent work,
you were really involved with
initiatives to raise awareness
around the role of crops like
millet and others for their for
the nutritional impact. I find
that work to be really great. I
love that it involved the word
smart and thinking through food
choices, not only through the
lens of nutrition, but also for
being climate smart. I'd love to
like for you to share a little
bit about that with our audience
as well.
Well, I'm a huge believer in
really taking more what I call a
triple bottom line, actually, in
the food system. So if you look
at the triple bottom line that a
company, a commercial company,
might take, and if you adapt
that for the food system,
basically what you get the
profit. The profit is a focus on
how the farmers, and especially
as I've worked in nonprofits,
especially the smallholder
farmers, how it's viable for
them. I. Um, but then the planet
is is in the food systems. It's
about climate change, and it's
about the natural resource
management, the soil, the water,
the biodiversity, and then that
people's side is about healthy,
nutritious food, and it's about
inclusion as well, because if
you're not bringing everyone
along in that solution, you're
not going to get to where you
need to go. But and it's about
making sure we have solutions
that take all that into account.
So that whole problem, which
makes it so much more complex,
but we work in our silos of
disciplines, we're not going to
get the best solution. We're not
going to understand the trade
offs. Now, you're not always
going to achieve everything all
at once, but you process and
understand how you what you can
do about that and how that
impacts the way you move
forward. Yeah, and I love that
you've, you know, really given a
lot of attention to the role of
staples. I feel like Staples
have long been overlooked. You
know, in here in the United
States, where I'm based, like we
get these fad diets, and they're
often about a superfood
ingredient or a radical
reduction of some entire food
group, but rarely do we really
have a focus on the quality and
diversity of our staples, like
the things that drive like 50%
of the average person's caloric
intake. And you know, in your
work with a and, and for those
of you who are listening, that's
the international Crops Research
Institute for the semi arid
tropics, there's a huge focus on
these staple crops, staple
grains, and really what it means
to re evaluate the nutritional
integrity of the things that
represent the lion's share of
our calories. And you know, and
I think that that led a lot to
that smart food initiative as
well. I just feel like it's
something that's often
overlooked in contemporary
culture, maybe we just take it,
take it for granted, like, you
know, in a place like the United
States, where most of us have
ample access to calories, it's
not it's usually a challenge of
how to eliminate staple foods
because, but then, in so much of
the world where there is food
scarcity and every calorie
counts, Things like millets,
like, really can make a huge
difference when you're looking
at mass population,
micronutrient deficiencies and
things like that. I would love
to have you just share some of
the things that you experienced
in that work.
Well, okay, so I am a big
believer in impacting the
staples. Actually, I recently
started a movement called
Smarter staples. So now the
reason for focusing on staples
is because, if you want to have
big impact and quickly, then you
need to do that through staples.
But, and there's two, two
dimensions to that that I took.
One is making our current
staples smarter and diversifying
our staples with small foods
like millet, and you need to do
to do both. And yeah, so the
focus on staples is only because
that's how you can have big
impact, and especially across
Asia and Africa, where, as you
sort of mentioned, staples are
huge part of the diet there. And
even as diets are changing,
staples are still really
significant part of the diet,
right? So particularly important
and can have very big impact,
and about the making our current
staples smarter. So it's about
that, that triple bottom line,
again, how you make them better
for the farmer, for you, the
consumer and and for the planet,
and then with diversifying the
staples. Well, that's where I
work with millets, because I I
termed what I called a food
system divide, and this is what
was the biggest challenge for
diversifying our staples, just
like you have an education
divide or a digital divide. So
what happened with the staples
is there was a huge emphasis on
investment and attention to just
a very, very small diversity of
guides. And of course, what I
call the Big Three, the wheat,
maize and race, received most of
the attention. It was the
research. It was the government
policy support, private
industry, investment, product
development, even the
development aid, the vast
majority went to the big three.
Now, when you invest in
something, you develop it, and
it does well, and the better
something does, the more it
attracts further investment, and
then it does and so on. So of
course, they have really well
developed value chains, really
well developed consumer
awareness and products, etc, and
they're on big scale. So when we
looked at how can we diversify
the staples, we realized that,
okay, we really need to focus on
just one or two staples at a
time and try to bring them back.
Into mainstream. Because if you
tried to do it with 50 different
statements, overwhelming, yeah,
and it's hard enough, and
there's, like you said, the
infrastructure gap is
significant. And so to, you
know, approach a value chain and
suddenly say, okay, not only do
we need to have more access to
like, the proper dehulling or
specialized
processing capacities, you know,
like one or two at a time or
clusters that need the similar
kind of access to value chain
processing makes a lot more
sense. It's just a lot more
doable, especially in areas that
don't have a lot of access to
capital. I mean, even here in
the US, our processing sector is
grossly undercapitalized, and
USDA recognized that recently
and set aside investment
specifically to really take on
that messy middle like, where
are the gaps. And the gaps that
were revealed were we had very
limited access to processing of
small cereals and specialty
crops, very limited processing
for things that need, like
specialized segregation, like
organic, allergen free, etc, and
also just in certain areas that
just were underrepresented, as
far as having access to
processing in their geographical
areas. So I'm grateful to the
USDA for responding to that here
in the United States, but I know
that that's something that is
experienced globally, because
we've really lost a lot of small
scale processing in the last 50
years, and I know you've seen
that firsthand in other
countries as well.
Yeah, well, I did a lot of work
with SMEs and these sort of
startup processing companies in
Millet and the reason was that
what we saw with the millets is,
and this is back a while ago
now, the very first gap was
driving the awareness and the
demand side. We really saw that
you needed to do that with
modern products and make it more
available and accessible on the
market. And of course, the SMEs,
like yourself, are really the
pioneers. I have so so much
regard, high regard, to the
really tough challenge. And I
always used to say, these SMEs
struggle just as much as the
farmers struggle. It's really
100%
Yeah, it is really tough, yeah,
and marketing is so such a huge
part of that, and you've spent a
lot of your life in that
marketing communication role,
and you know, honestly, no like,
you can have something that is
the most incredible superfood,
Prop, economical value chains
everything, and it will still
fall flat without the right
access to marketing and
communication channels. And what
have you found to be effective
in raising awareness for
underutilized crops like
millets?
Okay, there's no magic bullet.
Of course, you and you know
yourself, you just keep plodding
away. But you Yeah, so will the
approach that I took with the
smart food sort of global
movement make turning it into a
global movement, turning it into
something that could be owned by
others, it wasn't just owned by
the organization that I worked
for, and that's why we branded
it separately, and we created a
ambassador program with it, a
council of from people
organizations across Africa and
Asia. We then use that to drive
the message. But the aim, for me
was because we couldn't
influence consumers. We weren't
that sort of organization, or
you'd need a huge budget if
you're talking consumers. Yeah,
aim was to influence everyone
along that value chain and
influencers, so whether all the
way through to the farmers, the
food processors, the
researchers, the development
agencies, the NGOs, making
everybody aware of the value of
millets and the potential. And
now we have to be careful,
because we were all talking
about potential back then, and
we ran a lot of really, really
fun activities as well, like we
did a reality TV show in Kenya
that we ran where with sort of
celebrities and chefs, and it
attacked a lot of young people,
and They had to cook with
millets and legumes and products
I've never cooked with before.
And even the judges judging it
had never cooked with a lot of
these products before. It was
really fun. And we've got some
countries to start their own
annual millet fair. We did. And
of course, the the ultimate in
the end, which I think was a
good turning point for
awareness. It wasn't turning
point for the whole industry.
Was we initiated getting that
international year of millet
going. So it got a minister of
agriculture from India come with
us. We went to FAO. We did all
the rounds. Because when you've
got a minister, all the doors
open and. Ah, right. And we've
tried to find out, how do you
run an international How do you
get an international year
approved? Got all the inside
sort of help on how to do it.
And then we had to put through
the the recommendation through
the Indian government. And then
we had so many people helping,
so many people that really got
excited by this. As you know,
the Indian government would just
amazing. I've never seen an
international year with such
strong support from the
government right up to the Prime
Minister. I mean, India was
edible. It would be
unbelievable. Yeah,
that's incredible. I think so
too. Yeah, it is a case study,
and you know, I was watching it
from afar, you know, unfold, and
just seeing this massive
mobilization that was well
executed because it seemed to
hit so many different verticals
that are needed to be activated
simultaneously to raise
awareness. And then, lo and
behold, here we are not quite a
year after the UN year of
millets has, you know, finished,
and we have McDonald's launching
a millet based bun at Indian
McDonald's, which I'm not the
biggest fan of McDonald's, and
I'm and I not, you know,
whatever, to each their own, but
it's not a place that I choose
to eat. But I was absolutely
flabbergasted when I saw the
promotional materials come out
around the millet hamburger bun.
And I thought, this is, this is
like proof that that was so well
executed that we even got the
attention of a massive
multinational, you know, like,
like, top of the pile entity
like McDonald's. I mean, when it
comes to large international
entities, I mean, it's about as
big as it gets, and that they
are responding and taking
action, you know, we'll see how
it goes as far as consumer
adoption, but the fact that they
even did that at all, I just
found I was so tickled when I
saw that. I couldn't believe it.
Yeah,
no, I was really impressed. And
you've got to think, so, what's
behind that? You know, just the
strong Indian government support
for millets right up to the
Prime Minister, they made a
difference in the Indian
government, the cftri, iimr, all
the big research organizations
in India would have really been
behind that as well. It's a
really good example how advocacy
has led to some big change.
Yeah, yeah. And, you know,
I agree, yeah. And in speaking
with innovators in India and
talking to some of the women led
initiatives that they've created
brands that are doing all kinds
of product innovation. And as
someone who's been here doing
Milla innovation, I was a little
jealous when I learned about the
resources that were available
like to Milla innovators, as far
as loans to create new products
and to get product design,
packaging, r, d to the finish
line, and processing, microscale
processing, we definitely don't
have anything like that here.
It's been minimal support, and I
think that that's really helped
ignite a grassroots movement
that allows them to actually get
things like millets into
popularized products like
crackers and cookies and you
name it. I mean, I was blown
away at the degree of like
diversity in the different food
innovations that are coming out
of India, and with all of the
millets. And,
you know, India definitely is a
leader now in that sort of
startup space, being one of the
pillars there. Actually, April
said it was probably 15 or more
years ago, started up the very
first food incubator in India.
And then the Indian government
got excited by that, and so they
asked ikrasat to help them set
up, I think they set up about 13
or more around India. And of
course, it's just blossomed
after that. India really got the
government really got behind
understanding how important
startups and SMEs are. But what
I what I found is, okay, there's
fantastic support now for
someone to start up, the
challenge becomes to scale, and
I've seen so many of these SMEs
really struggle, and I don't
think we have the right support
mechanisms in place for scaling.
And I don't leave always just
leave SMEs alone. Sure, if they
get the big investment, they can
scale, but it's always reliant
on that huge investment, and
it's a really challenging time
in between. And I think,
absolutely, I think there's
solutions of doing more in what
I call collective marketing. So
you bring it together, you have
umbrella brand, umbrella to
criteria that you've got to be
part of. It's almost like you
certification to it, to being
part of that. So it's not just
random products.
Yeah. Right? There's a cohesive
purpose. Yeah,
so I really think that's a way
of the future to support more
SMEs.
I agree, especially when you're
creating a category essentially
around like a rediscovered
ingredient or something that is
new and different. Because we
know that if one brand comes in
and tries to champion like a
brand new ingredient. That's a
really tough road. It's
expensive, your tip of the
spear. People can be
distrustful, but if suddenly
they see it from five different
entities at the same time,
they're like, Wait a minute.
Maybe this is a thing. Maybe we
should try this. Maybe we should
be a little more receptive to
the marketing materials. And so
I think that aggregative
approach is really important for
building long term acceptance
and and shift in cultural norms
that adopt these underutilized
or opportunity crops.
And if you use a parallel, even
though there's quite a few
differences in India, they've
been very successful with pharma
producer organizations. There's
no branding to that. It's just
aggregation. But if you could do
something with SMEs, and it's
bringing them together, but
there is branding. They have
their individual brand, but you
have the this umbrella brand,
and and then you do the
collective marketing, because
individually, they can't afford
the level of marketing that's
needed, right,
right? Yeah, marketing isn't, is
an extremely big expense. And,
you know, there's a, there's,
there's grassroots marketing
that can be really effective,
but marketing strategy is a
science and an art, both. And I
have to say, you know, I've
learned the hard way of like,
how hard it is to try to grow
something without access to
quality marketing, and without
access to the capital, to higher
quality marketing. It's like
you're just banging your head
against a wall all day long
because you have to just kind of
cobble things together and, you
know, hope for the best, and
then you're just, it's like,
literally based on luck, not on
science, and not setting
yourself up for success. And,
you know, a lot of a lot of
people, especially innovators
and under, you know,
underrepresented groups,
socially and racially, but also
in underrepresented commodities.
It's like a double whammy, you
know, you're just, it's like
people are scared to invest the
money to drive discovery of
something new. You know,
talking marketing, the other
area I see that's challenging
the SMEs, is the product
development side. Now the big
companies have a team of good
technologies, yeah, and I've
found it's variable product,
millet products on the market,
and it's really, really hard to
get it right, and that's really
going to make the difference to
the industry taking off on it.
And at the end of the day,
people are just going to like
the product. They have to want
to eat it. And actually, for the
bit of time that I worked in the
rice industry, that was
something that really hit home
to me. When I'm in Asia and
people just want to eat rice. It
doesn't feel like a meal if they
don't have rice, they love rice,
and they always say rice is
live. They just want to eat it.
And I always used to think,
okay, how can we get there with
millet that they're not saying
I'm going to eat it because I
have a health problem, or
because I have diabetes, or
because I want to lose weight,
or because of any other reason.
I'm going to eat it because I
really, really want to eat it. I
love enjoying it, like I've been
creating.
I love a whole cooked sorghum,
and I love eating it. And, like,
honestly, like, I I haven't had
it. I've been really busy the
last few days and working very
long hours, like, for the last,
well, for the last few years,
but like, especially, like, the
last week, um, and I was like,
Man, I'm actually craving it.
Like, There's something I'm
craving in that, and that's a
cool thing. And my kids now,
even, like, my daughter's in
college, and she's like, Mom,
I'm just actually craving, like,
just plain cooked sorghum with,
like, you know, like a home
cooked meal. And I was like,
Okay, that's interesting,
because, you know, we've been
eating that in our family for
years, and kids come over that
have never had it, and they're
like, What is this? And it takes
them some time to warm up to it,
but then once you do, suddenly,
you crave it. It becomes part of
that fabric. And I think also
your gut microbiome, it starts
to crave those things as well,
because it does create a shift
in in all of those things. And,
you know, honestly, in in trying
to figure out what those early
little catch points are for
people like you said, you know,
eating for diabetes or eating
for health like I feel like the
nutritional story that's
associated with millets is
probably the best way to lead,
at least in the United States
and in these markets, to try to
get people to step out of their
comfort zone and try millet for
the first
time. What do you think? Yeah,
no, I absolutely agree it would
be crazy not to leverage that
amazing advantage that it has,
but you can't do it without a
great delicious, yeah, but it
gives it a competitive
advantage. And of course, there
is less known. Of course, there
are fewer studies done on
millets compared to other
products. So we were really
privileged to lead what I
believe is the world's largest
nutrition studies on millet,
including sorghum as well. So we
did, yeah, so we did systematic
reviews, meta analyzes, which is
basically studying the studies.
If you just do one more study,
you've just got another lot of
data, which is courses needed,
badly needed. But this was
saying, well, let's study
everything that's out there and
see what we can actually claim
and what you can't claim, and
where are the gaps. And so we
had, we had a big team globally.
So I've got a shout out, because
I can't claim it myself. We had
a lead nutritionist, Dr Anita.
We had the Indian National
Institute of nutrition with us.
We had Ian Gibbons, who was from
Reading University in the UK. We
had a medical doctor on the team
who was also a pediatrician, Raj
pandari. We had a statistician
from Japan. We had a couple of
other nutritionists, Rosie from
from Africa, and we had sweater,
who'd been UNICEF, and others.
So we had a really amazing which
is important to have, that
diversity really
is. I mean, it's like a
celebrity team in the scheme of
things, when it comes to like
global nutrition expertise,
like, those are well known names
in in that community, you know?
Yeah, yeah, no, no. And we were
really lucky. And actually a lot
of these people put their own
time voluntarily into this,
because we all believed in it.
We got some funding, thankfully,
to the Odisha government in
India. And he said, Okay, let's
get this done and finished. And
Marie, who's like an Asian
network supported us through it,
so we had a fantastic team. So
all these systematic reviews, so
we looked at diabetes that
actually had the largest number
of studies, and it did show that
consuming millet did reduce the
risk of type two diabetes, and
it did reduce the blood glucose
levels. So that was fantastic
news, and it definitely is one
of the big drivers why some
people move to millet.
I mean, especially in the day
and age where the vast majority
of adults are at risk of
developing or have already
developed type two diabetes
everywhere in the world. Like,
it's a, it's a thing.
It's huge. And every region in
the world is increasing with the
it
is, yeah, it's a it's becoming
evident that it's very few
populations are immune. And when
I, when you first sent me the
meta analysis, like I had, I had
read a few of the studies that
were listed in there and but
always in isolation, and so I
was that's partly what got me
excited about millets in the
first place, when I was working
in the ICU, like, you know, this
is intensive care unit. A lot of
people are there for
complications of diabetes. And I
was a diabetic educator, and I
thought, Why in the world are we
not recommending this as a
replacement staple to our
patients that are managing a,
you know, a diabe, a diabetic
friendly diet, and managing
their condition? And it's what
led me to it. So when I saw that
you guys had taken a large body
of that and indeed, able to
validate that it wasn't just a
one off study, it was literally
consistent. And I think that
that is so important, and we
need to talk about that more.
I've been I've need to
evangelize it more too, but from
a brand positioning, you had to
be really careful, because if
you're sharing information about
something having, you know,
effect on something like
diabetes, you can get in a lot
of trouble in the United States,
like, you know, like, it's
almost like you need to have it,
like, two steps removed, so that
way you're not making false
claims, right? Yeah, but I will
say, I mean, there's lots more
things that we looked at, not
just diabetes, but for diabetes,
and for all of them, we
definitely need more studies
at the length of other foods and
the variations, like, how is it
going to impact different ethnic
groups, different types of
millets, the different varieties
of millets. I mean, no, no.
Study started to go down to the
variety of millet. And one thing
that we did identify, and we did
a whole study on it, is how much
the nutrition value of millets
vary based on just the variety,
not just the type. So a type of
millet is proto millet, dull
millet, etc, but then within
that you've got lots of
varieties. Yeah, and so what we
did is actually we, as part of
all these studies, we then also
put together a nutrition table
for millet, but showing the
variation. So we collected as
many different varieties from
different countries in the
world, and looked at the
nutrition levels, and then sort
of created a range. So we don't
think we should use any of these
other nutrition tables that
exist, where they put one one
piece of data. They say, this is
how much iron millet. You cannot
do that, and it varies, as you
know, even how you grow it. It
varies. Again, we couldn't go to
that diff in our studies, but
that's where more and more
studies are needed.
I agree 100% and it's so
interesting now in our work with
the Montana project that I'm
involved in, it's a USDA Organic
markets development grant, and
we're developing a pro Sam
millet program there. And you
know, my goal is that it will
become like a culinary breeding
program where we're selecting
and identifying for the first
time in North America, what
varieties of millet actually
perform best for culinary
application and have the best
nutrient profile. You know, for
for our desired markets, it's
literally like the wild west out
there, like, you know, you've,
you've uncovered some materials,
Dr Deepak Santra in University
of Nebraska, Lincoln has done
some, some preliminary
evaluation there as well, just
looking at the differences. But
it's really still the Wild West,
and I think that that is one of
the reasons why it's had a lot
of trouble with adoption in
mainstream food systems and
manufacturing just there, the
flavor profiles are all over the
place, the performance profiles
are all over the place. And so
we're really excited that we'll
be one of the very first
programs here in North America
that's like really looking at
nutrition and culinary
performance, in addition to all
the awesome things that proso
millet, this is a proso millet
project brings to the table
like, as far as drought
resiliency and playing a role in
organic crop rotations in the
regions that we've targeted,
it's like a science. It is. I'm
really pleased to hear that
because, yeah, the industry, the
millet industry, is very
immature in that regard, wheat.
I mean, every big company will
know exactly which variety, if
they're making which master or
which bread or everything.
Whereas we don't have any of
that in millet, we're so far
behind in the investment in
research, which actually was a
key part behind when I was
trying to drive demand, it was
about also getting more research
funding into that, because we
can't develop the industry
without that. And even if you
look at the gene banks, I mean,
there is a gold mine there still
that is not explored for the
military. Profile, you can go
and what's really there. It's so
funny, and which is exciting.
It's only gotten very blossom
and get more amazing, amazing
things come out.
I agree. And, you know, and then
you start thinking about the,
you know, sophistication in the
market. And we're now, you know,
we are having this sudden trend
in really paying attention in
the US markets, at least, you
know, with the nutrient density
conversations like, Can we, can
we start having medically
tailored meals that really can
produce the effects that we want
from a medical evaluation
standpoint, and then create
systems that deliver consistent
meals to people on, you know, so
that it's a kind of a more
controlled environment. And this
is where I think millets will
eventually really hit their
stride in North America. But
it's been, it's been very, very
difficult. I mean, I've spent
eight years trying to build
markets for millets. And, you
know, recently, kind of, we
narrowed our focus to what it
seemed like the industry was
open to discussing, but I think
that we've just been too early.
So it's great that we have the
opportunity now to back up a
little bit and focus on that
germplasm, agronomy, farming
system and end use case from a
nutritional standpoint or
culinary application standpoint.
And I'm really enjoying it like
it's actually a lot of fun.
Actually, the good news is, even
though millets are further
behind from those big staples,
with the research level, we can
leapfrog a bit, because there's
so much new technology, like, if
you can use the eye for the
better faster, sort of rolling
through the gene banks, all the
new gene editing, the speed
breeding, all the genomics, all
the work that you can do that
will make the breeding so much
faster. We do have the advantage
of taking being able to use that
to go a little faster than
others, 100%
and again. Think that that's why
having more collaborative
process is also super important.
Because, you know, you look at
farming in the far north or far
south, and it's seasonal, you
get one shot a year to figure it
out. But then if you have
breeding programs, and you're
working with people on, you
know, both sides of the planet,
and then also in, you know, semi
tropical environments, where
they have a longer growing
season, suddenly we can expedite
variety trials in different
regions of the world and never,
like, lose that winter, like
that seasonal gap that really
slows down a lot of our regional
breeding programs that are
specific to our regions. I mean,
if we're wanting to go for
species that are adaptive for
this specific climate, we're
kind of stuck with a seasonal
problem. But if we're breeding
for nutrition and culinary
application, I mean, we can, we
can really step that forward
with a collaborative effort.
So the different geographic
areas and ecosystems. Then if
India is a brilliant example,
and it would be a gold mine too,
because you've got millets that
grow right down south in, say,
telonado, where it's the
tropics, you've got it growing
in the center of the dry land.
You've got it growing in
Rajasthan, which is a desert.
And then you've got up in
Uttarakhand, where it's it's the
mountains, way higher, higher
geographically than, you know,
Nepal and so, wow, amazing
variation. So it just goes to
show there's so much exciting to
explore for millet. Yeah,
absolutely. I think that's
always a good push back, like
when I'm, you know, having
lively discussions with
colleagues about, you know, we
have to do genetic modification
in order to advance food
options. And I'm like, Wait,
what about the other 90% of
plants and crops that we've not
even explored from a germ plasm
standpoint? And, you know, and
you know, people often, too,
also say, Oh, well, they're less
efficient. You know, they're
less productive. And I'm like,
Have you ever evaluated
productivity of sorghum as a
commodity against other
commodities like rice and wheat?
In our neck of the woods out
here, we've had some really
successful sorghum trials where
the sorghum has outperformed
wheat in yield, and so it really
starts to push that paradigm.
But sorghum has a lot more
breeding um than than proso
millet has that foxtail is and
Pearl. I mean, they're all
lagging behind, but to me, that
is a really great example of
like, what lays ahead as we
drive that innovation and and
develop the varieties that have
the yield and have the
efficiency, have the culinary
application. And you know what
the potential is? It's literally
like the to me, it's very
provocative, and I'm surprised
that not more, you know,
breeders are getting involved
with it. Yeah. Well, we
need the science, but I think if
we can marry that science with
also working with tradition and
countries and areas where
they've been growing, growing
the millets, they have the
traditional varieties. Knowledge
how we can leverage both, I
think, is it's going to be good
we move the industry forward.
How we move forward? Because
before, when I talked about that
food system divide and big three
that are well supported, we also
have to learn from the big
three, the weak maize, and learn
from their successes, and learn
from where things weren't done
right, to make sure we get it
right for millets, you know, we
still could end up with millet
that are mono cropped, that are
destroying the soil, that are
overusing the chemicals, not
Using the regenerative
agriculture. And we can end up
with millet that are polished
and refined, like rice as well.
At the moment, they're really
healthy because majority are
sold as a whole grain, and
that's another big thing I like,
pushes a whole grain and the
value of that, yeah. So we have
to be careful how we develop the
industry and guide it, and learn
from, you know, the lessons that
have from the past. Now, that's
a really good point, you know,
it's, it's interesting, because
in this process where we are,
you know, really just beginning
this pro so millet value chain
development and and we've been
targeting organic farmers in the
northern Great Plains and Inland
Northwest. And you know, it's
they're so hungry for crop
rotations because they know that
their soil is becoming depleted
because the market is only
demanding a couple of crops. And
you know, they have to grow
those crops because that's
what's paying the bills. And so
it's been really neat talking to
farmers across a very large
geographical area about their
needs and and in the role that
these diverse grains like
millets. I mean, proso millet is
the subject of that
conversation. But of course, we
talk about Pearl and foxtail
under you know, underrepresented
we. Groups like flax, legumes,
like all that diversity, and
really that's whenever I'm
talking to farmers, that is the
takeaway. Story is like, bring
me a market that rewards me for
diversity, and we will be more
effective as farmers. That's the
takeaway. And I think, I think
millets play a huge role in
that,
absolutely. Because even when we
talk about diversifying the
staples, it's not with just
anything. And that was the value
of millets that was good for you
the planet, and the farmer
vantages to it that it's a good
one to bring in for
diversification. But you know,
we've talked a lot about driving
the demand in the markets, which
is where I had focused on with a
lot of my work under the smart
food movement. But we've really
come to now feeling like we need
to also spend a huge amount of
time making sure it's then
really, really viable for the
farmer, which isn't just the
market, it's that whole
productivity. Because, like, we
are saying, the science and the
research is behind with the
level that we've been able to do
on it, and we really need some
breakthroughs to take it to that
next level. Absolutely,
you know, one of the things I've
discovered in this, you know,
kind of preliminary research and
into these, you know, the
questionnaires with the farmers
is they don't have access to
agronomy, and agronomists that
that are knowledgeable about
growing crops, like proso
Miller, and so that's a gap that
we've identified. And you know,
because they're in very remote
parts the United States where
there's really low populations,
in general, we're exploring ways
that we can develop like chat
GPT model modules that are
trained in um agronomy for that
crop that are like, as close to
as as you know, close to soil
type and as close to region as
possible, and then working with
extension and stuff, so that we
can provide them with tools,
like, so that they're out in the
farm, and they're like, I don't
know what to do about This. I
don't have an agronomist to
call. They can actually use a
technical service provider chat
and at least have something to
kind of walk them through. Like,
is this ready? Do I plant it
yet? What do I need to do? And,
you know, again, like technology
for this technology sake, can be
a big waste of time and money,
but technology, when it creates
democratized access to education
and resources that will up the
odds of them succeeding and de
risk them. You know, adding that
diversity and planting that new
crop, to me, that's a game
changer.
I love that idea, and using the
AI, we have to do that to move
ahead. So that's
needed access. So yeah, I love
it. Joanna, you and I, whenever
we get on a call together, I
think we could just talk for
hours. So I know I need to go to
Australia or wherever you're
located, because you do get
around quite a bit, and either
that or you can come to Idaho
and visit sometime. It's
beautiful, but, um, but where,
you know, I have a feeling our
listeners would love to learn
more, and, you know, follow your
work, maybe reach out to you
with questions. How should they
do that? What's the best place
to read more about your work?
LinkedIn is the best. Um, no one
else has a surname the same as
mine in the world. Yeah,
you and I both, keeps us honest,
right?
Yeah. So, no, okay, use the best
and connect and chat anytime.
Very happy,
yeah. And honestly, just
Googling you is amazing. Like,
you're one of those people that
if you Google, like, there's
reams of interesting stuff that
comes up, really, in that whole
realm of nutrition, human
health, Marketing, Economics and
agriculture, which is just a,
thank goodness, becoming a more
popular topic all the time. So
I'm happy that Google is
representing your work well in
that regard. So we'll make sure,
we'll put, we'll put some links
in the in the show notes, so
that people can reach out to you
and follow your work. And you
know, for those of you who are
listening, passionate millet
enthusiasts and more, please
take a minute to share this
podcast so other people can
learn about it and learn about
the extraordinary work that
Joanna has done with her career.
And thank you so much for
listening. Make sure to leave a
review as well. And thank you,
Joanna, so great to see you.
Thanks, Joanie,
this episode of the regenerative
by design podcast is brought to
you by snacktiv nation,
elevating climate smart crops
and regenerative supply chains
through innovative products and
transparent market development.
Thank
you for joining me on the
regenerative by design podcast.
Please take a moment to review
our channel on your favorite
podcasting service and share
this session with your friends
and colleagues via LinkedIn,
Twitter, Instagram, Facebook or
wherever you connect with your
community. You.